On March 29th the second Pauper Premier Event was held on MTGO. Just like the last time, MBC came out on top. Just like before, MBC was the most played deck in the top 8.
Let us look at the top 32.
Mono-Black Control seems to be the deck to gun for in the post-sanctioned Pauper world. This deck, one time relegated to second tier status during the era of PDC, is the force to reckon with if you want come out on top. Fully 18 MBC decks were played in the field of 107, and five made top 32, with three of those making the top 8.
However, this is not the same deck that SlashRus piloted to a win in the first PE. No, there are some subtle, but important differences:
Kobold's deck runs less removal and favors a more “in your face” discard option of Okiba-Gang Shinobi. This is a reaction to the skewing of the metagame. Shinobi is a key card against other control decks as well as in the mirror. A rise in MBC usually means a rise in Mono-Blue, where any one creature can often represent a true threat, since Shinobi is, in all likelihood, the single most dangerous creature to the Blue menace. Therefore, it makes sense to see a large portion of Black decks running the ninja as a foil to the other monoliths of the format.
The other big innovation is the Relic of Progenitus in the sideboard. It seems that this time around, people were afraid of MBC's recursive power and many sideboards packed this innocuous artifact that just so happens to have game against decks like Storm and Threshold as well.
In second we have an old standby in three color Cloak. Those who know me will understand when I say that I am not a fan of this deck, regardless of its high placing, in that it seeks to build a deck that optimizes the namesake Aura rather than have the Aura optimize the deck. That being said, bobafett's deck was perfectly positioned to work through the field with strong sideboard options and the Tendril's proof Guardian of the Guildpact. If decks like this catch on, however, I expect MBC to move away from a full suite of Tendrils and move to Diabolic Edicts and start incorporating the full four Unmakes main.
In third we have what can only be described as Pauper's version of GW Haterator. Another Cloak deck, this one ran the full eight Protection from Black bears. Combined with the incredibly strong Armadillo Cloak and Shield of the Oversoul, this deck was positioned for a run at the top and appears to have come ever so close. The great thing about this deck is that it can be easily modified and streamlined for a more diverse metagame taking the same on curve beats and resilient creature package into any field that does not pack Swirling Sandstorm.
Fourth brings something rather innovative. A Martyr Lock deck has long been discussed on the PDCMagic boards and was once the bane of the Euro events by “never ever netdecked nick#####.” Nick would often run a four color special that would lock you out with Grim Harvest and Kami of False Hope, and run a whole kitchen sink of cards that would make you go “buh?” Bry, however, streamlined that package, finding a whole slew of creatures that accomplish the same effect as the Kami lock while fitting in quite a few spicy win conditions. Both (Envicar's Justice) and Cenn's Enlistment are god long game choices, especailly when combined with the evasive beats of a Grotesque. Moving forward, I'm wondering if this deck would be better served with Blind Hunter on the flying slot and Twisted Abomination over Guardian.
The future, however, does not look great for this deck. Much like Storm, this is the type of deck that does incredibly well when people are not ready for it. Now that it made top four and is being paraded around Tournament Practice, people will have a plan.
Speaking of Storm, Ben Ani took the deck to a fifth place finish, incorporating the current trend of both Grapeshot and Empty the Warrens main to help fight the hate that was present in most Sliver decks.
Between the MBC captured sixth and eighth places, we have Affinity sitting comfortably in seventh. Our hero, intherain, has amalgamated three distinct builds- Rush of Knowledge, Disciple of the Vault/Krark-Clan Shaman, and Glaze Fiend- and tuned them into one impressive beast. This is an Affinity deck that can attack you from multiple angles, although gives up some of the top end attackers without Quicksilver Behemoth. This version plays a combo-control game, often clogging up the ground until it either has bigger creatures than you or has enough pieces to kill you outright with Disciple.
Not featured here is the rediscovered tech of Affinity running Storm. Back in the PDC Dark Ages, Affinity would often run a singleton Temporal Fissure so that after it emptied its hand, it would take out half the permanents on the opponents board, setting them back to turn three, and proceed to just win. While Fissure is far too expensive nowadays, many decks have taken to running Reaping the Graves as a way to refuel after a Crypt Rats activation. Tech.
Tenth place takes us to our next new archetype, and would you look at that- RG Aggro. I will not go into this deck in detail, except to say that gnomo made some changes that I do not agree with, but seem to have been spot on for the day, with more Shroud creatures and some dudes that cannot be stopped by Artifacts. I wonder if these changes were made for power purposes, or the expense of Mongrel and Fanatic. Out of the three people running an adaptation of the RG deck I proposed, gnomo was the only one to finish in the top 32.
After two more Affinity decks, we see hybrid Goblin/Burn deck. Lacking the true utility of Sligh or RDW, this deck tries to force through a ton of damage, but unlike Burn does so with creatures. This is an interesting turn of events for the Red deck as it seeks to improve the MBC pairing. One wonders if it can adopt the Reaping the Graves tech and perhaps move another step closer, a la Goblin Bidding of Block gone by. The deck in 16th place takes another look at what the new face of Red might look like:
20th place holds the first “Burn” deck:
In 14th and15th respectively we see relatively standard builds of MUC and GoblinStorm. Well, it would be Standard if MUC was not running Impulse. This, however, is a fantastic choice. This allows Blue to run more effective answers, as it can just dig four deep and find exactly what it needs. I would not be surprised to see this change catch on.
To call the deck in 17th odd is an understatement. A hybrid of Clout decks from PDC Standard and Dragonaut aggro from Classic seasons gone by, this deck is just chock full of good cards. There is gold to be found in this deck, but to me, there is work to be done. Could be I'm wrong, though.
The deck in 18th is something near and dear to my heart in UG aggro-control, but calling this deck Deep Dog is an insult to the Savage [D]astard. This is much more a pure tempo deck, seeking to just keep the opponent off balance. However, some choices, like Essence Warden, just seem odd, where a card like Werebear or Springing Tiger just seems, well, stronger.
19th place and another new archetype to the top tables of Pauper in Mono-Blue Aggro. This deck hybridizes the old Fish builds with some new Faerie technology and seeks to fix late game lulls with limited standout Rushing River and interesting choice Shrieking Drake, which can reset a Pestermite or Spellstutter Sprite. This is definitely a deck that warrants further investigation.
After another MBC, we come to the first Sliver deck in 22nd place and then another in 23rd. I fear that with the rise of MBC, this deck has met its match for the time being. This drop off could be for a number of reasons: people got sick of attacking, the threat of MBC loomed too large, or perhaps the people who were attracted to Pauper that played Slivers simply moved to another pursuit. The Sliver menace in 31st ran the interesting Shinen of Life's Roar, giving it a true advantage in the mirror. If only it appeared more often that day.
The 24th spot gives us our first look at a competitive Pauper Elves! Deck. If the deck can ever find away to combat Crypt Rats on a regular basis (Wrap in Vigor anyone?), it might be able to crack the top 16. Note the Springleaf Drum fueled Melodies and sideboard tech.
28th gives us another interesting look at Mono-Green aggro.
26th place, and our first three color Blink deck. Could the bane of PDC have met its end in competitive Pauper?
The top 32 was rounded out with more Slivers, Red, MUC, and Affinity. Nothing special. We do, however, see a truly evolving metagame. While MBC is still on top, the density of Blue control is down and Slivers is a shadow of its former self. Affinity is definitely a rising deck, and those rogue designers are coming out of their shells to have a say in the new format.
However, before the next step can be taken, the deck that dethrones MBC must be uncovered. Traditional MUC has the chops to take on the menace, but falls to aggro, which in turn tends to fall to MBC.
No matter what, the month of testing for the next PE should be an interesting one indeed.
A big thank you to Lee Sharpe and the folks over at Wizards for giving me access to the lists from the PE. You guys are awesome!
Keep slingin' commons-
-Alex
16 Comments
you have the first comment wrong. The second deck uses 2 more removal cards and 2 less creatures. Not the opposite, so I kind of think you messed up the first metagame prediction. Also both decks use the same number of Okibas main deck: 2.While slashrush still has 1 in his side making HIS list the one with the okiba advantage.
2 for 2 with the Pauper recaps. Thanks for all your work putting this together.
Was the 20th place Burn deck omitted by accident? The colon teased the deck list and this red mage was slapped with an MUC deck instead!
;-)
Can you please post the 20th place burn list? Thanks again.
I am sorry about the lack of quality this time around. All lists can be found here:
http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=p9e5F564yA-N2Uswc1TJBBA
-Alex
Thanks for the quick response! Keep up the great work.
Hey! nice to see my altered RG aggro on this list! Just for clarification, i was worried about Mono-blue, so thats why the nacatls and the beetle. I traded the fanatics for some burn (shock) to get more surprise on creature removal.
Actually it was my first Pauper tournament, and good to know i did good. This will be one of my favorites formats.
Lots of possibilities...
c ya!
Why do white decks eschew cop: black in their sideboards? From what I've seen, MBC can't handle that card at all. They have to attack with Dross Golems, Crypt Rat activations 1 at a time, or get lucky with duress or distress, but the game is basically over once that enchantment hits the table.
Because even after you stick a COP: Black you have to win. I'm undefeated against White and GW Sliver decks with COPB with MBC. You time them out by attacking every turn, removing any important threats, etc.
That makes a lot of sense - I've just been trying to think of outs, but never considered timing them out. I guess it's only bad when blink boards it in and you can't exactly kill their threats without a ton of rats
Actually that sounds like a load of crap.
wont the white player just stick a pro black guy and win?
No good monowhite deck will be losing to MBC any time soon. Order of Leitbur is a good MB in a MBC-ruled meta, a 2/1 that can certainly be 3/1 first strike takes out basically all creatures in this format even if the opponent isn't playing black. Then 3-4 Obsidian Acolyte on the SB, the ultimate card against MBC, lets you punch through their defenses, keeps yourself unattackable, and negate the effect of Tendrils.
If the deck isn't monowhite and only has COPB, sure I can see some flops, but it depends on how many evasive creatures they have vs. how many the MBC player can take out.
Heh, MBC has Edicts to deal with our Protection from Black guys...
My comments are assuming your monowhite deck is aggro since I haven't really seen any successful monowhite control decks that aren't stomped by MUC. Edict isn't going to deal with 24-26 creatures. There's really no answer to an SB'd in Obsidian Acolyte. Even against monowhite control I'd say edict is iffy (how creature light are they going?).
He's going to time you out. Ding.
Way back when I was advocating WW as a deck, I never lost to MBC, even when they would cast repetitive Corrupts, Tendrils, and Rats. The secret would be keeping another creature on the board with an Order of Leitbur. At this time, I was also running 4 Riftwatchers main, which would often keep me in positive life totals regardless of how hard MBC tried to burn me out. I ran Obsidian Acolytes in the board, but no COP. Rather, Prismatic Strands does a better job since you can just catch MBC off guard.
-Alex
Hi!
iim testing maryr deck and its awesome...and really fun (but not for my rivals...)
im searching for another finisers other than Guardian of the Guildpact and Cenn's Enlistment because are really slow.
any sugestions?